For many, the single-family house with a garden represents an almost unchallenged ideal. Yet, often overlooked are its ecological impacts, like land sealing and increased heating demand, economic factors such as the cost of infrastructure development, and societal consequences, including the perpetuation of social inequalities and traditional gender roles.

THESE COSTS ARE BORNE BY SOCIETY AS A WHOLE.

beitraege/bauschild 231113_forschungswerkstatt_efh_bauschild_web_dsc0632.jpg
The Construction Sign on the Campus of the BauhausUniversity Weimar for summaery23, Photography: Florian Marenbach, 2023

The eight-member research team has set up a construction sign in Weimar to inform the local community about the various crises associated with homeownership, including social, ecological, and architectural-planning aspects.

In an effort to make the research processes, discussions, and internal considerations more accessible and tangible to civil society, the team sought an unconventional medium and format to serve as an intermediary.

The construction sign was selected as an ideal platform to present initial findings in a succinct manner and to reach a wider audience beyond academic circles. This medium was specifically chosen for its typical association with promoting the lifestyle of living in a single-family house with a garden.

beitraege/bauschild 231113_forschungswerkstatt_efh_bauschild_web_l1002030.jpg
The construction sign on the Campus of the Bauhaus-University Weimar for summaery23, Photography: Florian Marenbach, 2023

The five statements on the construction sign are as follows:

In Germany, there are 16.1 million single-family houses SFH 1 , accounting for almost 67% of all residential buildings. They dominate the housing stock. 2 (Destatis, 2022, p.16; Destatis, 2021)

SFH have a significantly higher land consumption. Their inhabitants live on average in 157 m², almost 79 m² more than in multi-family houses MFH. 3 . (ibid)

The rural areas in Thuringia are experiencing a continuous population decline. Potentially, 36,000 SFH will be vacant by 2030. However, 1,500 SFH are still being built annually in the Free State. (Thüringer Ministerium für Infrastruktur und Landwirtschaft, 2018, p.74f.)

SFH incur municipal investment costs for roads, sewage, drinking water, and power lines. The development costs for an SFH are 8 times higher than for a compact MFH. 4 (Bundesstiftung Baukultur, 2018, p.60)

Homeownership reflects high income and wealth inequality in Germany. The median net wealth of real estate owners reached a record high of €364,800 in 2021. For renters, it was €16,200. (Deutsche Bundesbank, 2021)

  1. 1 Single-Family House
  2. 2 Inventory of residential buildings in the years 2010–2021 with one or two apartments.
  3. 3 MFH = Multi-Family House
  4. 4 SFH with 1,000 m² of land per housing unit and an MFH with 100 m2 of living space per housing unit.
beitraege/bauschild 231022_forschungswerkstatt_efh_bauschild_dsc0771.jpg
The construction sign on the Campus of the Bauhaus-University Weimar for summaery23, Photography: Florian Marenbach, 2023

Location

beitraege/bauschild 231218_bauschild_bhf_l1003768.jpg
The construction sign on the main station forecourt, Photography: Florian Marenbach, 2023

The construction sign was situated on the campus of the Bauhaus University Weimar from July to the end of October, coinciding with summaery23, the university's annual exhibition. Positioned in an open area accessible to both the university community and external visitors, the construction sign offered preliminary insights into the research findings.

Its placement on a greenfield area, earmarked for densification and development in the university's development plan, highlighted the issues and challenges associated with newly developed single-family house zones on the outskirts of many small towns. The familiar format of the construction sign, coupled with its striking, signal-colored text, initially captured attention, paving the way for a dialogue and discourse on the presented topics.

Until the end of November 2023, the construction sign was positioned in the forecourt of Weimar’s main train station. 5 The selection of this public urban space was significantly influenced by the political dimension of the topic, underscoring the contentious nature of the content displayed on the sign. After numerous unsuccessful location inquiries, we secured permission for a one-month exhibition period. Despite the challenges faced, we are gratified to have situated our statements at a key infrastructural site in Weimar.

A condensed version of the construction sign's content is also on display as an installation in the Bauhaus Museum. This exhibit was part of the Wohnen theme year, showcased in the summer of 2023.

  1. 5 Green area on the main station forecourt, Schopenhauerstraße 2, 99423 Weimar

Layout Construction Sign: Enno Pötschke

Sources

Continue

18:51

Laura Fritsche, Janina Hain, Madita Pyschik, Cora Sauré

Between new beginnings and habit. The role of urban planning in dealing with single-family housing neighbourhoods

The vision of a socio-ecological spatial development is difficult to reconcile with the single-family home. Based on this observation, Laura Fritsche, Janina Hain, Madita Pyschik and Cora Sauré investigated the long-term consequences for spatial development as part of their thesis projects for the M.Sc. and B.Sc. Urbanistik. The four theses combine thorough analyses with the development of concrete ideas and proposals on how urban planning could respond to the various challenges of the single-family home. In spring of 2024, the authors produced this abridged versions of their texts to present their findings to a broader public on the Forschungswerkstatt website. Their contribution is framed by an introductory text and a conclusion written by Johanna Günzel, Sandra Huning and Michael Schwind, Chair of Urban Planning, who had, together with their colleague Carsten Praum, supervised the thesis projects.

Related

08:55

Johanna Günzel, Kassandra Löffler

The dream of a house with a garden – Is there another way?

beitraege/der-traum-vom-haus-mit-garten-geht-das-nicht-auch-anders 231031-fw-mariapol-02-353535.jpg
A garden (of your own)?, Illustration: Marijpol, 2023

The decision to buy and live in a single-family house with a garden is not always rational: the long-term financial burden, the sole responsibility for a house, from the basement to the roof, the location and immobility … even on an individual level, there are many arguments that actually speak against this housing decision. Despite these arguments, it is a persistently popular form of housing. In the sub-project Wohnwünsche und ihre Erfüllung zwischen Gemeinschaftsprojekt und Eigenheim, we asked ourselves why?

Related

08:21

Michael Schwind, Elodie Vittu

What does the single-family house have to do with home and land ownership?

In recent years, the single-family house has undergone various changes. However, one aspect has remained constant: the concept of private ownership persists as the underlying logic of the single-family house. Single-family house developments and home ownership, both in terms of land and housing, are closely intertwined as a result.

Related

03:30

Julia von Mende, Hanna Maria Schlösser

The Single-Family House for Disposition – Empirical knowledge and designing further

In Germany, there are 16 million single-family homes, each with one or two apartments (Destatis, 2022, p.16). To grasp the vast scale of these existing buildings, consider this illustrative calculation: If each house accommodated five individuals, the 83 million residents of Germany could theoretically all have a roof over their heads. This scenario highlights a significant potential for transformation within the realm of urban planning. However, such a transformation can only be achieved in collaboration with the residents.